diff --git a/nise-backend/src/main/kotlin/com/nisemoe/nise/Models.kt b/nise-backend/src/main/kotlin/com/nisemoe/nise/Models.kt
index dc21ee1..dce55dd 100644
--- a/nise-backend/src/main/kotlin/com/nisemoe/nise/Models.kt
+++ b/nise-backend/src/main/kotlin/com/nisemoe/nise/Models.kt
@@ -65,6 +65,8 @@ data class SimilarReplayEntry(
     val replay_id_2: Long,
     val user_id_1: Long,
     val user_id_2: Long,
+    val user_banned_1: Boolean,
+    val user_banned_2: Boolean,
     val username_1: String,
     val username_2: String,
     val beatmap_beatmapset_id: Long,
diff --git a/nise-backend/src/main/kotlin/com/nisemoe/nise/database/ScoreService.kt b/nise-backend/src/main/kotlin/com/nisemoe/nise/database/ScoreService.kt
index 0d151a4..44244b2 100644
--- a/nise-backend/src/main/kotlin/com/nisemoe/nise/database/ScoreService.kt
+++ b/nise-backend/src/main/kotlin/com/nisemoe/nise/database/ScoreService.kt
@@ -390,6 +390,8 @@ class ScoreService(
     fun getSimilarReplays(condition: Condition = DSL.noCondition()): List<SimilarReplayEntry> {
         val replays = getSimilarReplaysRecords(condition)
         return mapSimilarReplays(replays)
+            // Filter scores where the imports have been out of order and the stolen replay's user has been banned
+            .filter { !it.user_banned_2 }
     }
 
     private fun mapSimilarReplays(replays: List<Record>) = replays.map {
@@ -400,6 +402,9 @@ class ScoreService(
         var userId1 = it.get(osuScoreAlias1.USER_ID, Long::class.java)
         var userId2 = it.get(osuScoreAlias2.USER_ID, Long::class.java)
 
+        var userBanned1 = it.get(osuUserAlias1.IS_BANNED, Boolean::class.java)
+        var userBanned2 = it.get(osuUserAlias2.IS_BANNED, Boolean::class.java)
+
         var username1 = it.get(osuUserAlias1.USERNAME, String::class.java)
         var username2 = it.get(osuUserAlias2.USERNAME, String::class.java)
 
@@ -422,6 +427,10 @@ class ScoreService(
             userId1 = userId2
             userId2 = tempUserId
 
+            val tempUserBanned = userBanned1
+            userBanned1 = userBanned2
+            userBanned2 = tempUserBanned
+
             val tempUsername = username1
             username1 = username2
             username2 = tempUsername
@@ -444,6 +453,8 @@ class ScoreService(
             replay_id_2 = replayId2,
             user_id_1 = userId1,
             user_id_2 = userId2,
+            user_banned_1 = userBanned1,
+            user_banned_2 = userBanned2,
             username_1 = username1,
             username_2 = username2,
             beatmap_beatmapset_id = it.get(BEATMAPS.BEATMAPSET_ID, Long::class.java),